The Supreme Court Will Hear A Case Of A Worker Who Says She Was Demoted For Being Straight

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case of an Ohio woman who says she faced workplace discrimination over her heterosexual identity. The case may be the first of its kind. It examines the lengths members of “majority groups” must go to prove that they were discriminated against by “minority” groups.

Marlean Ames worked for 20 years at the Ohio Department of Youth Services, a state agency that oversees the confinement and rehabilitation of juvenile felony offenders. In 2014, she was promoted to serve as the administrator of the Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA), a 2003 federal law that seeks to track and end sexual assaults in all detainment facilities.

In 2017, a gay woman named Ginine Trim became Ames’ new supervisor. In December 2018, Trim gave Ames a performance evaluation that said Ames mostly “met” all of her job expectations and had an “opportunity to improve” in three areas. Then, in April 2019, Ames applied and interviewed to become the Department’s Bureau Chief of Quality — she didn’t get the job.

One month later, the agency’s Human Resources department called Ames into a meeting where they terminated her role as PREA administrator and demoted her to her former role, reducing her pay from $47.22 an hour to $28.40 an hour,court documents allege

The agency’s director and assistant director who oversaw Ames’ demotion are both heterosexual, and at different times, they provided different reasons for her demotion. Once, they mentioned that her position was an “at-will” role whose work could be terminated at any time; another time, they said that they wanted a worker who would regularly exceed (rather than just “meet”) the job’s expectations.

The following December, the department hired Alexander Stojsavljevic, a 25-year-old gay man, for the PREA administrator position and chose Yolanda Frierson, a gay woman, as its Bureau Chief of Quality. Ames filed a discrimination charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and then filed a lawsuit. Both a district court and the 6th U.S. Court of Appeals ruled against Ames.

Ames claimed that she had faced discrimination based on her sexual orientation, something banned by Title VII after the Supreme Court’s 2020 Bostock v. Clayton County decision. The decision ruled that workplace discrimination against sexual orientation and gender identity are forms of sex-based discrimination.

However, in its summary judgment, the district court said Ames had failed to prove that she was a member of a “protected class” of people who have historically been discriminated against for their personal characteristics. The court also said Ames failed to substantiate “background circumstances” proving that LGBTQ+ people had made the decisions against her or that they had discriminated against other heterosexual workers before in the past.

Ames herself acknowledged that the agency’s heterosexual director and assistant director made the decision to hire the gay man who took the Bureau Chief of Quality position.

The larger question at issue — according to Raymond Kethledge, a district court judge who disagreed with the legal reasoning in his colleagues’ decision — is whether it’s fair for Ames to have to prove “background circumstances to support the suspicion that the [department was] that unusual employer who discriminates against the majority.”

“Twice in one year, the Department promoted an arguably less-qualified gay employee in a manner adverse to Ames; and in promoting one of those employees, Yolanda Frierson, the Department circumvented its own internal procedures because Frierson lacked the minimum qualifications for the job,” Kethledge wrote.

Kethledge argued that if Ames had been treated similarly for her race, the court would’ve considered that enough to substantiate her discrimination claim.

“Our court and some others have construed this same [‘background circumstances’] provision to impose different burdens on different plaintiffs based on their membership in different demographic groups,” Kethledge wrote. “Nearly every circuit [court] has addressed this issue one way or another. Perhaps the Supreme Court will soon do so as well.”

Subscribe to the LGBTQ Nation newsletter and be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.

Related Posts

Elon Musk PRÉVOIT D’INTERDIRE LeBron James de X après avoir accepté « The Woke Show » de la NBA

Elon Musk PRÉVOIT D’INTERDIRE LeBron James de X après avoir accepté « The Woke Show » de la NBA

Elon Musk, le magnat controversé derrière des entreprises comme Tesla, SpaceX et le réseau social X (anciennement Twitter), a relancé la conversation publique. Selon des rapports récents, Musk envisagerait de…

Read more
Diddy FACE À UNE PEUR EXTRÊME après qu’Elon Musk ait publié une liste non censurée et des photos associées de stars qui lui sont associées.

Diddy FACE À UNE PEUR EXTRÊME après qu’Elon Musk ait publié une liste non censurée et des photos associées de stars qui lui sont associées.

Elon Musk défie Hollywood : révélations chocs sur Diddy, Epstein et secrets cachés Dans un monde où les motivations cachées de l’industrie du divertissement commencent à apparaître au grand jour,…

Read more
Il y a 10 minutes choquant : Elon Musk publie une liste explosive et des photos de stars liées à Diddy – « La vérité doit éclater. »

Il y a 10 minutes choquant : Elon Musk publie une liste explosive et des photos de stars liées à Diddy – « La vérité doit éclater. »

Dans un monde où les arrière-pensées de l’industrie du divertissement sont révélées au grand jour, Elon Musk se révèle être une voix perturbatrice. Connu pour ses opinions audacieuses et sa…

Read more
Hier soir, Elon Musk, le patron de X, a ruiné la carrière de JLO si rapidement que les gens n’ont pas eu le temps de comprendre ce qui s’est passé

Hier soir, Elon Musk, le patron de X, a ruiné la carrière de JLO si rapidement que les gens n’ont pas eu le temps de comprendre ce qui s’est passé

Elon Musk, le magnat de la technologie et actuel patron de X (anciennement Twitter), est une fois de plus au centre de la controverse, mais cette fois le drame implique…

Read more
Elon Musk choque le monde en amenant son fils de 3 ans au Grand Prix de F1 à Austin au milieu d’un drame de garde avec Grimes

Elon Musk choque le monde en amenant son fils de 3 ans au Grand Prix de F1 à Austin au milieu d’un drame de garde avec Grimes

Dans un geste inattendu qui a attiré l’attention des fans et des médias, Elon Musk a récemment amené son fils de 3 ans au Grand Prix de Formule 1 à…

Read more
Elon Musk découvre que son employée de Tesla est sans abri, le lendemain, elle reçoit le choc de sa vie !

Elon Musk découvre que son employée de Tesla est sans abri, le lendemain, elle reçoit le choc de sa vie !

Le monde connaît Elon Musk comme un innovateur milliardaire, l’homme derrière Tesla et SpaceX, dont la mission est de révolutionner les industries et d’inspirer le changement. Mais que se passe-t-il…

Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *